| Date | Location | Result | |
| May 9, 2009 | Lancaster, Pa. | Tufts 20, St. John Fisher 18 | Box score |
| 05/06/09 | Pittsford, NY | St. John Fisher 17, College of Wooster 12 | Box score |
| May 03, 2009 | Hioboken, N.J. | St. John Fisher 10, RIT 9 | Box score |
| 05/02/2009 | Hoboken, N.J. | St. John Fisher 16, Stevens 12 | Box score |
| 04/25/09 | Pittsford, NY | St. John Fisher 17, UTICA 13 | Box score |
| 04/19/09 | Oneonta, NY | St. John Fisher 18, Hartwick 5 | Box score |
| 04/18/09 | Hoboken, N.J. | Stevens 17, St. John Fisher 14 | Box score |
| 04/16/09 | Pittsford, NY | St. John Fisher 16, SUNY Geneseo 5 | Box score |
| 04/11/09 | Elmira, NY | St. John Fisher 18, Elmira 10 | Box score |
| 04/10/09 | Ithaca, N.Y. | St. John Fisher 15, Ithaca 9 | Box score |
| 04/05/09 | Pittsford, NY | RIT 8, St. John Fisher 7 | Box score |
| 04/04/09 | Alfred, NY | St. John Fisher 15, Alfred University 5 | Box score |
| 04/01/09 | Pittsford, NY | NAZARETH 14, St. John Fisher 13 | Box score |
| 03/28/09 | Williamsport, Pa. | St. John Fisher 17, Lycoming College 9 | Box score |
| 03/26/09 | Brockport, NY | St. John Fisher 18, BROCWLAX 11 | Box score |
| 03/24/09 | Geneva, N.Y. | William Smith 9, St. John Fisher 7 | Box score |
| 03/13/09 | Hilton Head, S.C. | Wesleyan University 13, St. John Fisher 10 | Box score |
| 03/11/09 | Hilton Head, S.C. | Gettysburg 17, St. John Fisher 15 | Box score |